Kakutougi P4P-Ranking thread?

[Faster]

Looking at Shooto's p4p-ranking threads over at sherdog...I was just wondering if whether we could have a thread dedicated to such a discussion over here?

Here are my lists so far:

Heavyweights:

1Fedor Emelianenko
2Antonio Rodrigo Nogueira
3Mirko Filipovic
4Sergei Kharitonov
5Andrei Arlovski
6Aleksander Emelianenko
7Kazuyuki Fujita
8Josh Barnett
9Mark Hunt
10Fabrizio Werdum
11Tim Sylvia
12Heath Herring
13Pedro Rizzo
14Ricco Rodriguez
15Mike Kyle - Big upside

Frank Mir – too inactive
Ryoto – don’t see as a HW


Light Heavyweights:

1Wanderlei Silva
2Shogun
3Chuck Liddell
4Ricardo Arona
5Antonio Rogerio Nogueira
6Randy Couture
7Alistair Overeem
8Hidehiko Yoshida
9Renato Sobral
10Quinton Jackson
11Kazuhiro Nakamura
12gor Vovchanchyn
13Kazushi Sakuraba
14Ninja Rua
15Yuki Kondo


Featherweights:

1Kid Yamamoto
2Gilbert Melendez
3Jens Pulver
4Alexandre Noguiera
5Yoshiro Maeda
6Ivan Menjivar
7Rumina Sato
8Masakazu Imanari
9Joao Roque
10Mitsuhiro Ishida

[Lord Gaul]

What the hell is Silva still doing at one? WHat the hell is Fujita doing in the top ten? What the hell is Jackson doing at 10? Man there is to many what the hells to say right now.

When was this list made?

[Faster]

:middlefin Vikings suck!

[K++s]

Why do you have weight classes for a P4P ranking?

Doesn't P4P = Pound for Pound?

Isn't the point of a P4P list to have everyone in the same pool?

[( o Y o )]

Why do you have weight classes for a P4P ranking?

Doesn't P4P = Pound for Pound?

Isn't the point of a P4P list to have everyone in the same pool?

LOL...good point.

Just to check though, you want a similar deal to shooto's whereby we have one thread constantly updated with the members rankings, and one thread to discuss them?

[Faster]

Yeah....that's what I meant.
K++s is a smartarse!

[Tony]

.54

[heckyl]

.54


??????@#?@!?#@?#~@?@~#



p4p lists are too hard and cause problems. just look at the lame ass one sherdog just came up with. makes no fucking sense. just like this guys .54 post. WTF is up with that? why here?

[( o Y o )]

^^I agree with all three points you raise!! lol

[Razor Bump]

It should look like this baby....

Pound 4 Pound

1. Fedor Emilianeko
2. Wanderlei Silva
3. Shogun
4. Matt Hughes
5. Takanori Gomi
6. Georg St. Pierre
7. Dan Henderson
8. Ricardo Arona
9. Chuck Liddell
10. Mark Hunt

[heckyl]

um, Mamaru Yamaguchi??

[heckyl]

how about Kid fucking Yamamoto? you put mark hunt over both of them?? KID could realistically fight at 132 and he is out there putting the hurt on 155lbers and beating up people in K-1 max even though he is always outsized. had he not got cut 30 seconds in vs Palling, he would have more than likely won that fight and be 14-0. Palling is to KID what TK is to Fedor. KID is easily top 3 P4P if this ranking system was worth a shit.

[Razor Bump]

Yeah.... big deal this was just an example of what it should look like. You want my real opinions it would look a lot different.... well not to much but hey

[heckyl]

well, "it should look like this" usually means that is should look like that. :)